Digital copy of a Letter from Mental Health Services Manager Dylan A Southern to Chief Executive Graham Jennings, and an Internal Enquiry and report into allegations made against Mrs Jane Maguire, formally House Parent at the Blanche Pierre Family Group Home. Report from Dylan A Southern, Manager of Mental Health Services, to Graham Jennings, Chief Executive. [Some details redacted].

View WD000599.pdf | Download WD000599.pdf




February 23rd 1999 - February 23rd 1999

Scope and Content

1. Refers to conclusion of internal inquiry regarding the conduct of Jane Maguire, and support of a formal disciplinary hearing regarding the conduct of Jane Maguire be held concerning her tenure as House Mother of Blanche Pierre Family Group Home. Summarises belief Jane Maguire committed and condoned acts of emotional and physical abuse towards children in her care. Provides details of allegations of emotional and physical abuse made by former residents and staff relating to the conduct of Jane and Alan Maguire, also mentioning supporting evidence in house diaries. Concludes children at Blanche Pierre lived in a state of anticipatory anxiety, and refers to traumatic events having also affected children prior and during their admission to care. Refers to Jane Maguire's departure from Blanche Pierre in 1990. Notes denial by Jane Maguire during an interview with Dylan Southern concerning her use of a punishment where children's mouths were washed out with soap. States that Jane Maguire's inability to respond honestly to allegations put to her leads to her necessary removal from employment working with vulnerable people. Refers to witness statements to be offered by Jane Maguire from former residents of Blanche Pierre, noting that the statements are supportive of the Blanche Pierre regime only before 1986, and that a former member of staff's statement to States of Jersey Police in support of Jane Maguire appears to ignore records made in the Blanche Pierre diary indicating that cruelty existed within the Family Group Home. States that witnesses available to support Dylan Southern's conclusion will stand by their original allegations, and that Police statements from former residents and [Residential] Child Care Officers will be made available to the hearing panel. Intends to call Director of Community and Social Services Anton Skinner, Child Care Officer Sarah Brace, and States of Jersey Police Inspector Barry Faudemer as witnesses. Concludes recommendation to the disciplinary panel that Jane Maguire be dismissed from the employ of the Health and Social Services Committee. 2. Contains summary of findings relating to Jane Maguire's employment by Children's Services, mentioning contract at Haut de la Garenne, appointment as House Mother at Blanche Pierre Family Group Home. Comments on Alan Maguire's acceptance of role as House Father at Blanche Pierre without salary. Reflects on circumstances under which children would be placed at Blanche Pierre. Relates to the role of Jane Maguire at Blanche Pierre, detailing her training, experience and skills in caring for children, and the needs of the children under her care. Details Jane and Alan Maguire's appointment to Blanche Pierre in March 1980, and Jane Maguire's reflections in 1999 regarding her experiences caring for the children under her care during her ten years at Blanche Pierre. Refers to Jane Maguire's "retirement" from Blanche Pierre in 1990, and Jane Maguire's opinion the retirement was due to a change in child care policy at Children's Services. Refers to personal histories of children at Blanche Pierre under the care of Jane and Alan Maguire, and requests from Jane Maguire for Dylan Southern to interview former residents of Blanche Pierre. Details allegations of emotional and physical abuse at Blanche Pierre being made to Child Care Officer Dorothy Ingles by care staff employed at Blanche Pierre. Refers to report by Dorothy Ingles [Inglis] regarding the allegations to Children's Officer [Anton] Skinner, and [Anton] Skinner's meeting with the care staff alleging to have witnessed abuse towards children at Blanche Pierre. Refers to meeting with individuals including Acting Homes Manager G [Geoff] Spencer and Anton Skinner. Refers to [Anton] Skinner's interviews with Jane and Alan Maguire dated 30 April 1990, in which Jane and Alan Maguire admitted emotional and physical abuse of children in their care, disputing the degree and maintainign they would discipline their children in the same manner. Describes further interview with Jane Maguire, and her inability to recall the interviews mentioned above. Refers to interview between Dylan Southern and Jane Maguire dated 29 January 1999 concerning allegations of physical abuse, and Jane Maguire's denial of using physical abuse as a form of punishment. Refers to contradicting evidence to Jane Maguire's statement, citing [Blanche Pierre] diary notes, Jane and Alan Maguire's admission to [Anton] Skinner, reports by care staff to [Anton Skinner] regarding abuse, and statements given to States of Jersey Police by children formally under Jane and Alan Maguire's care. Comments on events following Jane Maguire's departure from Blanche Pierre, described as "retirement". Addresses States of Jersey Police investigation into emotional, physical and sexual abuse by Jane and Alan Maguire at Blanche Pierre. Concludes that there is evidence showing Jane Maguire, whilst employed as Housemother at Blanche Pierre Family Group Home, committed emotional and phyiscal abuse towards children in her care. Recommends Jane Maguire's dismissal from employ of Health and Social Services Committee. [For a copy of the Letter from Mental Health Services Manager Dylan A Southern to Chief Executive Graham Jennings with differing levels of redaction, see C/D/AW1/A3/10/WD00589].


Blanche Pierre Family Group Home
Children's Services
Health and Social Services
Health and Social Services Committee
Highlands College
Mental Health Services
States of Jersey Police
Brace, Sarah
Faudemer, Barry
Inglis, Dorothy
Jennings, Graham
Maguire, Jane
Maguire, Alan
Skinner, Anton
Spencer, Geoff
Southern, Dylan


Blanche Pierre | Highlands College | abuse | allegations | child abuse | childcare | Children | children's homes | Child Care Officers | Children's Officers | children's services | corporal punishment | Committees | Correspondence | diaries | directors | emotional abuse | employment | evidence | Family Group Homes | fathers | injuries | IJCI | interviews | inspectors | investigations | Letters | meetings | mental health | Managers | Notes | parents | physical abuse | punishments | policies | Police | police officers | retirements | Residential Child Care Officers | residents | residential homes | reports | summaries | sexual abuse | statements | staff | Soap | training | visits | witness statements | witnesses


1 pdf file



Level of description


Access Restriction

PDF file - please click on the link to download

Closed until



C/D/AW1/A3/10/WD000599This item»
Search query time: 0 seconds • Page build time: 0.009273898601532 seconds